403. Pushing a Car Uphill

The Government is trying to push a heavily laden car uphill. Ministers strain against the back of it. They announce new plans, targets, subsidies and reforms. They urge everyone to push harder.

But the car is becoming heavier, the hill is becoming steeper, and the people pushing it are becoming exhausted.

This is a useful picture of Britain’s economic predicament. The Government still assumes that economic growth can be restored if it finds the right policies. It tries tax incentives, planning reform, public investment, borrowing and regulation. When these fail to produce growth, it concludes that even more intervention is required.

The possibility that sustained growth is no longer affordable is rarely considered.

What makes the car so heavy?

Britain must support an enormous structure of government, public services, debt, regulation, infrastructure and administration. It must also maintain an ageing population, an ageing energy system and an ageing stock of roads, railways, water pipes, hospitals and public buildings.

Much of this structure was created during a period of abundant and relatively cheap energy. That energy supported industrial production, international trade, mass transport, expanding public services and rising household consumption.

Energy is still available, but obtaining and using it has become more expensive. More money, materials and effort must be devoted to maintaining the systems upon which the economy depends. Less remains for genuine expansion.

Debt has temporarily concealed the problem. Borrowing allows the country to continue consuming more than it can presently afford. It does not remove the weight from the car. It adds another load which must eventually be carried.

The symptoms

The first symptom is persistently weak economic growth. Governments announce recoveries, but improvements are small and often disappear after allowing for population growth and inflation. Many people become poorer even when the official economy is said to be growing.

A second symptom is rising taxation without visibly improving public services. The Government collects more money, yet people wait longer for medical treatment, roads deteriorate, councils reduce services and police become less visible. More revenue is required merely to prevent further decline.

A third symptom is the growth of public debt. Borrowing is increasingly used to meet ordinary expenditure rather than to create productive assets. A growing share of taxation is then required to pay interest on earlier borrowing.

Another symptom is the repeated failure of large projects. Costs rise, completion dates retreat and plans are reduced or abandoned. Britain can still design impressive projects, but increasingly struggles to afford the materials, energy and skilled labour needed to complete them.

Businesses experience the same pressure. Energy, wages, rents, interest, insurance and regulation all become more expensive. Customers have less money to spend. Profits narrow and investment is postponed. Shops, pubs, farms and small manufacturers close, while surviving businesses reduce staff.

Housing provides another symptom. Governments promise large numbers of new homes, but builders cannot construct them at prices ordinary households can afford. The difficulty is described as a shortage of planning permissions or land. The deeper problem is the widening gap between construction costs and household purchasing power.

Employment becomes less secure. Vacancies decline, young people struggle to enter settled work, and self-employment becomes more precarious. At the same time, the State creates additional administrative work in an attempt to manage the consequences.

Infrastructure begins to fail more frequently. Water leaks, power shortages, transport disruption and communications failures become harder and more expensive to prevent. Each system depends upon many other complex systems. A failure in one place can rapidly spread elsewhere.

People also notice a decline in quality. Goods become less durable. Services become harder to contact. Telephone menus, websites and automated systems replace people, but do not always solve problems. Citizens spend more of their own time doing work once performed by banks, utilities, councils and government departments.

These are not separate accidents. They are symptoms of a society trying to maintain an industrial system which has become too heavy for the economic energy available to support it.

Pushing harder will not solve the problem

The usual political answer is to demand greater productivity. Workers must work harder, businesses must invest more and government departments must become more efficient.

Some improvements are certainly possible. Waste should be reduced and useful technology should be adopted. But efficiency alone cannot overcome the physical and financial limits facing the whole economy.

Indeed, greater complexity can make matters worse. New computer systems, reporting requirements, regulators, consultants and managerial layers are introduced to improve performance. Each requires money, energy and skilled labour. The machinery intended to lighten the load can add still more weight.

Nor can the Government solve the problem simply by borrowing more. Borrowing may help the car move a few yards, but the additional debt makes the next part of the climb harder.

Lightening the car

If the car is too heavy to push uphill, there are only three realistic choices. The load must be reduced, the journey must be shortened, or a less demanding destination must be chosen.

This means accepting that the purpose of the economy cannot be the endless expansion of consumption. The priority must become the dependable provision of essentials: food, water, shelter, heat, care, basic health services, useful work and social order.

Many activities will have to move closer to the people who need them. Food can be grown and processed nearer to its market. Repair can replace frequent replacement. Care, small-scale energy, practical education and essential manufacturing can be organised within localities.

National government will still be needed for defence, taxation, telecommunications, specialist medicine, the railway network and other functions which cannot sensibly be provided locally. But it must stop trying to control every detail of economic and social life from the centre.

Localism is therefore not an attempt to overthrow the State. It is a practical response to the State becoming overloaded. It transfers manageable responsibilities to a scale at which people, resources and consequences can be connected.

The Government is presently trying to push the old industrial economy uphill. Every Budget asks the public to push harder. Every new crisis adds another suitcase to the boot.

The sensible response is not to blame the exhausted people behind the car. It is to recognise that the load has become too great, remove what is no longer essential, and begin building an economy based upon locality, resilience, quality and sufficiency.


Discover more from Chatting about Localism

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply