Download As PDF

• In law, a highway is a right enjoyed by the public to pass and repass. The adjoining landowners may own the surface, but the public right-of-way sits above it. In most rural lanes, the highway authority does not own the freehold. It maintains the surface and verges, but the subsoil usually belongs to the frontagers up to the centre line.

Highway authorities are normally county councils or unitary authorities under the Highways Act 1980. They have a statutory duty to maintain highways that are maintainable at public expense.

As the economy shrinks, traffic declines, and maintenance budgets shrink, authorities may conclude that certain minor lanes are no longer viable as publicly maintained carriageways.

Stopping up a public highway

To close a lane as a public highway, the authority cannot simply lock a gate. The public right must be lawfully extinguished.

There are three principal mechanisms:

1. Stopping up under section 116 of the Highways Act 1980.
   The highway authority applies to the Magistrates’ Court for an order stopping up the highway on the ground that it is unnecessary. Notice must be given to frontagers and the public. Objections can be heard in court.
2. Stopping up in connection with development under section 247 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990.
   This is used where development makes the highway redundant. The Secretary of State makes the order following consultation.
3. Diversion rather than extinguishment under section 119 of the Highways Act 1980.
   The route may be altered instead of removed.

The authority must demonstrate that the highway is unnecessary for public use. In a shrinking economy, this argument would increasingly rest on measurable traffic decline, lack of strategic function, and the unsustainable cost of maintenance.

Transfer of responsibility and ownership

Stopping up extinguishes the public right. It does not automatically transfer ownership, because the highway authority often does not own the land beneath the surface.

In most rural lanes, once stopped up:

• The land typically reverts fully to the adjoining landowners up to the centre line, free from the public right of way.
• If the authority owns any strip of land, it may dispose of it under section 263 of the Highways Act 1980 or under general local authority disposal powers.

A formal extinguishment order should clearly identify boundaries to prevent later dispute. Land Registry updates may be required.

Reclassification as a bridleway

Instead of completely stopping up, a carriageway may be downgraded to a bridleway or restricted byway. This retains public passage, but only for specified user classes.

The categories of public right of way are defined in the Countryside and Rights of Way Act 2000 and related legislation. A bridleway allows passage on foot, horseback, and bicycle, but not motor vehicles.

Reclassification usually proceeds by:

• A traffic regulation order removing vehicular rights, or
• A public path extinguishment and creation order under the Highways Act 1980.

The process requires consultation, advertisement, and an opportunity for objection. If objections are not withdrawn, the order may be determined by the Secretary of State after inquiry.

Who maintains a bridleway?

If the former highway becomes a public bridleway:

• The highway authority remains responsible for maintaining the surface so that it is passable for the class of users entitled to use it.
• Adjoining landowners remain responsible for cutting back overhanging vegetation from their side.
• The authority is not required to maintain it to vehicular standards.

If the route is fully extinguished and becomes private land, maintenance becomes the landowners’ responsibility entirely.

The financial and structural context

In a shrinking economy that does not return to previous levels of throughput, the issue is structural. Traffic volumes decline not temporarily but permanently. Fuel usage falls. Tax revenues contract. The network, designed for expansion, becomes oversized relative to demand and public finance.

The legal system already contains the mechanisms required. What changes is not the law but the frequency with which those powers are used.

Over time, minor lanes may move through three stages:

• Full public carriageway
• Downgraded bridleway or restricted byway
• Fully extinguished highway, reverting to private land

Each step reduces the public maintenance burden.

The critical requirement is procedural order. Public rights cannot simply lapse. They must be lawfully extinguished or modified. If done carefully, the contraction of the highway network can be managed without legal confusion and without leaving ambiguous strips of land.